Big Down Payment or Keep Your Cash? FHA vs Conventional, With the Real Math
A buyer has more money than his FHA loan requires and hasn't told his lender. Here is what that silence can cost on a $500,000 South Florida home, and every question worth asking before you decide.
The short answer
At today's 7%+ mortgage rates, a larger down payment usually wins on cost. On a $500,000 home, moving from 3.5% FHA to 20% conventional cut the payment by about $807 a month and saved about $82,000 over 10 years. Keep the cash instead when your credit is under about 680, your reserves would fall short, or you'll sell within two to three years.
The scenario: the buyer who kept his savings quiet
Here is a situation I see more often than people think. A buyer is under contract on a $500,000 home in Broward. His FHA loan needs about $40,000 to close: $17,500 for the 3.5% down payment and roughly $22,500 for closing costs and prepaids.
What his lender doesn't know is that he has about $165,000 in savings. Maybe he's afraid a big balance will trigger more paperwork. Maybe the money came from abroad and he worries about questions. Maybe he simply believes the less the bank knows, the better.
The problem is simple. A loan officer can only recommend what fits the file in front of them. If the file says "$45,000 in assets," the conversation never reaches conventional financing, PMI that cancels, or a 20% down payment with no mortgage insurance at all. Nobody did anything wrong, and the buyer may still be leaving tens of thousands of dollars on the table.
Asked out loud
"Hey, should I put more money down on my house or keep it in the bank?"
If your mortgage rate is around 7% and your savings earn about 4%, paying down the loan usually earns more. That's especially true when the extra money also removes mortgage insurance. Just don't drain the cash you'd need for emergencies, hurricane deductibles, or repairs.
The four paths, side by side
Same buyer, same $500,000 home, same $165,000 in savings. The only change is the loan structure. Rates reflect late-October 2026 averages and assume a credit score around 740.
| A · FHA 3.5% | B · FHA 10% | C · Conv. 10% | D · Conv. 20% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Down payment | $17,500 | $50,000 | $50,000 | $100,000 |
| Cash to close | $40,000 | $72,500 | $72,500 | $122,500 |
| Cash left in the bank | $125,000 | $92,500 | $92,500 | $42,500 |
| Loan amount | $490,944 | $457,875 | $450,000 | $400,000 |
| Rate (30-yr fixed) | 7.25% | 7.25% | 7.375% | 7.375% |
| Principal & interest | $3,349 | $3,124 | $3,108 | $2,763 |
| Mortgage insurance / mo | $221 | $188 | $150 | $0 |
| How long MI lasts | Life of loan | 11 years | ~8.8–10 years | None |
| Total payment (PITI + MI) | $4,779 | $4,519 | $4,466 | $3,971 |
Start with mortgage insurance, because it’s the cost nobody sees coming
FHA and conventional loans both charge mortgage insurance when you put less than 20% down. They work very differently.
FHA: MIP (two charges, and one may never leave)
Conventional: PMI (priced by your credit, and it cancels)
The takeaway: with good credit, conventional PMI is cheaper and temporary. FHA MIP on a minimum-down loan is a permanent line item until you refinance. Credit flips the math, though. At a score near 640, PMI on 10% down can run around 1.10% a year, roughly $412 a month here, and FHA becomes the better tool. That's why the first question is always your credit score.
What the choice costs over time
This is interest plus mortgage insurance only. Taxes and insurance are identical across all four options, so I left them out.
| Interest + MI paid | A · FHA 3.5% | B · FHA 10% | C · Conv. 10% | D · Conv. 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| After 5 years | $186,273 | $172,631 | $170,729 | $143,759 |
| After 10 years | $359,637 | $333,297 | $330,459 | $277,741 |
| After 30 years | $768,022 | $689,668 | $686,894 | $594,572 |
| 10-yr extra vs. D | +$81,896 | +$55,556 | +$52,718 | — |
Notice the 10-year gap between A and D, $81,896. It's almost exactly the $82,500 of extra cash D put down. In other words, over 10 years the bank collects roughly the same amount you chose to keep.
The opportunity cost: what is that cash really earning?
The fair way to judge a down payment is to treat it as an investment and ask what it returns. Paying down a mortgage "earns" exactly what you stop paying.
Why is the return so high? Because the extra money doesn't just retire 7%+ debt. It also deletes mortgage insurance, and on FHA it skips the 1.75% upfront premium. Very few safe places pay 10% to 11% after tax.
Net worth after 5 and 10 years
To compare fairly, every buyer starts with the same $165,000 and spends the same $3,570 a month on principal, interest and mortgage insurance. Whoever has a lower payment saves the difference at 4.25%. Home value grows 3% a year, and net worth is counted after a 7% cost to sell.
| Net worth | A · FHA 3.5% | B · FHA 10% | C · Conv. 10% | D · Conv. 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 5 | $236,517 | $243,464 | $253,512 | $269,806 |
| Year 10 | $402,388 | $416,428 | $428,238 | $463,319 |
| D ahead of A by | $33,289 at year 5 · $60,931 at year 10 | |||
Stress test: even if the saved cash earned 6% net instead of 3.3%, D still finished about $41,700 ahead at year 10. With zero appreciation, D was about $61,400 ahead. The large down payment won every version I ran, as long as the buyer kept healthy reserves.
Time: is this the first home or the last home?
How long you stay changes the weight of every number above.
First home (3–7 years)
- Closing and selling costs eat most early equity. In year 1, about 88% of payment A goes to interest.
- You'll want cash for the next move-up down payment.
- If you sell in under 2–3 years, the down payment choice matters less than buying right.
- Plan to sell or refinance within 7 years? FHA's life-of-loan MIP hurts less, but the upfront 1.75% is gone either way.
Last home (15+ years or retirement)
- Lifetime cost dominates: D pays $173,450 less than A over 30 years.
- A lower fixed payment protects a fixed income.
- Sale proceeds from a previous home often fund the larger down payment.
- Florida homestead portability can carry up to $500,000 of Save Our Homes savings to the new home if you establish it in time. Ask the property appraiser.
How equity builds (3% appreciation)
| Equity (value − loan) | A · FHA 3.5% | C · Conv. 10% | D · Conv. 20% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | $9,056* | $50,000 | $100,000 |
| Year 3 | $70,770 | $110,113 | $158,586 |
| Year 5 | $116,290 | $154,391 | $201,640 |
| Year 10 | $248,223 | $282,464 | $325,741 |
*Financing the $8,444 FHA upfront premium means the buyer starts with less equity than the $17,500 down payment.
The market: stable area or unproven community? Up or down?
Your down payment is also your shock absorber. In an established neighborhood with steady demand, prices tend to recover faster. In a new or unproven community, with builder phases still selling and investor resales competing, a dip can last longer.
South Florida in late 2026 shows both sides. Single-family homes have held up better than condos. Broward's median condo price fell to $235,000 in September 2026, down 14.5% from a year earlier, according to MIAMI Realtors data.
Downturn test: prices drop 10% in year one, then grow 3% a year
| Equity after a 10% dip | A · FHA 3.5% | B · FHA 10% | C · Conv. 10% | D · Conv. 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| End of year 1 | −$36,192 | −$3,443 | $4,251 | $53,778 |
| Loan-to-value, year 1 | 108% | 101% | 99% | 88% |
| If forced to sell in year 3 (after 7% costs) | −$31,607 | +$428 | +$7,737 | +$56,209 |
The buyer will recover. The real question is what happens if life forces a sale or refinance during those years. Underwater, Buyer A can't sell without bringing a check to closing and can't refinance into a lower rate easily. Buyer D can do either. That's the honest case for a bigger down payment in an uncertain market. The honest case against it is that Buyer D has only $42,500 in the bank if the job, the roof, or the hurricane deductible hits first.
Taxes: does the deduction balance the extra interest?
No. This is the most common myth in the conversation. A deduction returns your tax rate on each dollar, never the whole dollar.
Two more checks. You only benefit if itemized deductions beat the 2026 standard deduction of $32,200 for married couples filing jointly. Florida has no state income tax, so for most local buyers the itemized total is mortgage interest plus property taxes. Spending a dollar to save 22 cents is never a strategy. It only softens the loss.
The questions most buyers never ask
Mortgage insurance, time, market and taxes are the core. Here's the rest of the formula I walk through with every buyer before we pick a loan.
- 1. What's your credit score?Under about 680, FHA often wins. At 740 and above, conventional usually wins.
- 2. How much cash stays after closing?A good floor is 6 months of the full payment plus your hurricane deductible, which is often 2% to 5% of dwelling coverage.
- 3. Do you carry higher-rate debt?Paying off a 22% credit card or a 9% car loan beats a bigger down payment.
- 4. Is your income stable?Self-employed, commission, or a single income usually means keeping more cash.
- 5. Where is the money, and can it be documented?Funds from abroad, cash deposits, and recent transfers need a paper trail. Disclose early, not at the last minute.
- 6. Is it a condo?FHA needs the building approved. Florida's newer reserve and inspection laws can bring special assessments, so keep cash on hand.
- 7. Could you buy down the rate instead?On $400,000, one point ($4,000) at about 0.25% saves $68 a month, a 59-month break-even.
- 8. Would you recast later?Many conventional loans allow a recast after a lump-sum payment. FHA loans generally don't.
- 9. How much can the seller contribute?FHA allows up to 6%. Conventional allows 3% under 10% down, 6% from 10% to 25%, and 9% above 25%.
- 10. What's the plan for the cash?A business, tuition, or a future DSCR investment purchase at 20% to 25% down may need it more than the house does.
- 11. Will you rent this home out later?A lower payment improves future cash flow. FHA requires you to live in the home first.
- 12. Is retirement funded?Don't skip an employer match to make a bigger down payment.
Case studies
Illustrative composite scenarios built from common South Florida buyer situations. They are not actual clients, and the names are fictional.
Andrés and Valentina, townhome in Pembroke Pines
$500,000 price, 740 credit, $165,000 saved, two incomes. Their lender pre-approved FHA because that's what they asked for. They plan to move up when a second child arrives.
Moving from FHA 3.5% to conventional 10% costs $32,500 more at closing. It lowers the payment by $312 a month, cuts interest and insurance by about $15,500 over 5 years, and leaves them about $17,000 ahead in net worth at year 5. They still keep $92,500 in reserves for the next move.
Mr. and Mrs. Herrera, single-family in Weston
Ages 62 and 64, selling a paid-off home in Kendall, moving closer to grandchildren. Income in retirement will be fixed. They have $300,000 from the sale and planned to "keep it safe" with FHA minimum down.
At 20% down on the same $500,000 home, the payment is $807 lower than FHA minimum, and they pay $173,450 less over the life of the loan. A lower payment also keeps their debt-to-income comfortable on retirement income. Even after 20% down and closing costs, about $177,500 stays in reserves.
Daniel, new build in a community still selling phases
The builder still has two phases to release, and investors are reselling early units. The builder offers a rate buydown through its preferred lender. Daniel has $120,000 and a W-2 job.
Prices in a young community can drift lower while the builder competes with itself. In the downturn test, 3.5% down left a buyer $36,000 underwater in year one, while 10% conventional stayed near break-even. Builder incentives are often worth more than extra down payment, so the strategy is to negotiate the buydown and closing-cost credit first.
Mariela, older condo near Fort Lauderdale
$260,000 condo in a 1980s building, 700 credit, $90,000 saved. The association is funding structural reserves under Florida's newer condo laws, and a special assessment is likely.
First question: is the building FHA-approved? If not, FHA is off the table regardless. Second: with Broward condo prices down 14.5% year over year, this is not the place to lock all her cash into the unit. A likely assessment means liquidity matters more than the last bit of mortgage insurance savings.
The decision framework
Put more down when…
- Credit is 720+ and the extra cash removes mortgage insurance.
- You'll own the home 7+ years, or it's your last home.
- Reserves stay at 6+ months after closing.
- Your savings earn less after tax than your mortgage rate.
- The market is soft and you want an equity cushion.
Keep the cash when…
- Credit is under ~680 and FHA pricing is clearly better.
- A bigger down payment would drain your emergency fund.
- You carry higher-rate debt or have no retirement savings.
- You'll sell or move up within 2–3 years.
- You need the money for a business, an investment property, or condo assessments.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to put 20% down or use FHA with 3.5% down?
It depends on your credit score, the cash you keep after closing, and how long you will own the home. In our $500,000 example at late-October 2026 rates, 20% down on a conventional loan lowered the payment by about $807 a month and saved roughly $82,000 in interest and mortgage insurance over 10 years. FHA with the minimum down keeps more cash liquid, which matters when reserves would otherwise run thin.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
On FHA loans with less than 10% down, the annual mortgage insurance premium lasts for the life of the loan, so the usual way out is refinancing. With 10% or more down, the annual premium ends after 11 years. FHA also charges a 1.75% upfront premium, which is usually added to the loan balance.
When does PMI come off a conventional loan?
Under federal law, PMI cancels automatically when the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the original value, and you can ask to remove it at 80%. In our 10%-down example that is roughly 8.8 to 10 years on the normal schedule. Extra principal payments or appreciation backed by a new appraisal can move that date up, subject to lender rules.
Is a bigger mortgage worth it for the tax deduction?
Rarely. A deduction gives back only your tax-bracket share of each dollar of interest, for example 22 cents, and only if your itemized deductions beat the 2026 standard deduction of $32,200 for married couples filing jointly. Mortgage insurance is deductible again starting in 2026, but that deduction phases out between $100,000 and $109,000 of adjusted gross income.
Should I tell my lender about all of my savings?
Yes. Your loan officer can only compare FHA and conventional options using what you disclose, and extra reserves often strengthen an approval or improve pricing. Any money you use must be documented, including funds from outside the U.S., so bringing it in late can delay or derail a closing.
What happens to my down payment if home prices drop?
A larger down payment works as a cushion. In our example, a 10% price drop in year one left the 3.5%-down FHA buyer about $36,000 underwater, while the 20%-down buyer still held about $54,000 in equity. At 3% yearly appreciation afterward, it takes about 4.6 years to get back to the purchase price.
Can I keep my cash now and pay the loan down later?
Yes, but the result depends on the loan type. On a conventional loan, extra principal can remove PMI sooner, and many lenders offer a recast that lowers the payment after a lump-sum payment. On an FHA loan with less than 10% down, extra principal reduces interest but does not cancel the annual mortgage insurance.
Let’s run your numbers, not an example
Bring your price range, credit score and savings. I'll lay out FHA vs conventional side by side, privately, before you commit to a loan. English or Spanish.
Message Joaquin on WhatsApp YouBetterCallMe.comSources
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, week of October 22, 2026 (30-year fixed average 7.32%).
- The Mortgage Reports daily rate tables, October 23, 2026 (conventional 30-year ~7.37%, FHA 30-year ~7.22%).
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 (FHA annual MIP schedule).
- One Big Beautiful Bill Act (P.L. 119-21): mortgage insurance deduction restored for 2026; SALT cap $40,400 for 2026.
- IRS 2026 inflation adjustments: standard deduction $32,200 married filing jointly.
- MIAMI Association of Realtors / SEFMLS market statistics, September 2026.
All figures are illustrative estimates based on the assumptions stated above and late-October 2026 market averages. They are not a loan offer, a rate quote, or tax or legal advice. Mortgage insurance, rates and eligibility depend on your credit, property and lender. Confirm loan terms with a licensed loan officer and tax treatment with a CPA before acting. Joaquin Gutierrez, Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker, Canvas Real Estate.